Best Pencils for Realistic Drawing (2025 Review & Buyer’s Guide)

Looking for smooth, dark pencils for realistic sketches? Here's my honest review of the best graphite pencils after 3 years of drawing portraits and eyes.

Introduction

If you're serious about pencil drawing, you already know the tool you use makes a huge difference.

After three years of sketching portraits, eyes, and realistic faces, I've tested more than 10 pencil brands — and only a few really deliver the smooth blending, dark tones, and clean erasing I need.

Today, I'll share my top choices for the best pencils for realistic drawing, plus what I actually use in my own tutorials.

(💡Tip: You can watch my full YouTube video review here 👉 [https://youtube.com/shorts/YwaDeu5DkiM])

✏️ Why Choosing the Right Pencil Matters

Not all pencils are created equal. Some scratch your paper, while others blend like butter. The right pencil helps you:

Control your shading easily

Create darker values for realism

Erase cleanly without damaging your paper

Save time while sketching

If you're struggling with grainy or patchy shading, your pencil might be the problem — not your skill!

🏆 My Top 3 Pencil Brands for Realistic Drawing

1️⃣ Faber-Castell Graphite Sketch Set ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Best For: Beginners and intermediate artists

Price: Around $12–$20

Buy Here: 👉 Check Price on Amazon (Amazon.com: Faber-Castell Graphite Sketch Pencil Set - 6 Graphite Pencils (2H, HB, B, 2B, 4B, 6B), Drawing Pencils and Sketching Supplies : Office Products)

Why I Love It:

Very smooth graphite for blending
Clean, dark lines without scratching
Easy to erase mistakes
Comes with an eraser, sharpener, and tin box

Drawbacks:

Softer pencils (6B–8B) break easily if dropped.

💬 My Experience:

I used this set for almost all my "realistic eye" tutorials. It gives consistent tones and doesn't leave shiny spots on paper. Perfect for practice and clean sketches.

2️⃣ Staedtler Mars Lomography Set ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Best For: Professionals and advanced sketch artists

Price: $18–$25

Buy Here: 👉 Check Price on Blick Art(Amazon.com : Staedtler Mars Lumograph Art Set | Drawing Kit with Art Pencils, Drawing Pens, Eraser and Double Hole Sharpener (61 100) : Office Products)

Why I Love It:

Premium graphite texture
Very dark, matte finish
Minimal smudging
Perfect control for layering tones

Drawbacks:

A bit more expensive — but totally worth it for portrait artists.

💬 My Experience:

I use Staedtler pencils for my portrait commissions. They deliver perfect contrast and look great on video or scanned art.

3️⃣ Derwent Graphic Drawing Pencils ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Best For: Portrait sketchers and realistic art lovers

Price: $15–$22

Buy Here: 👉 See Price on Amazon (https://www.amazon.com/Derwent-Graphic-Drawing-Pencils-34215/dp/B000J6BAV8)

Why I Love It:

Excellent range of hardness (9H–9B)
Great balance between soft and firm
Works well with textured paper

Drawbacks:

The barrel finish can feel slippery during long sessions.

🧾 Comparison Table

Brand Price Smoothness Best For Rating

Faber-Castell $12–20 ⭐⭐⭐⭐ Beginners 9/10

Staedtler $18–25 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Professionals 10/10

Derwent $15–22 ⭐⭐⭐⭐ Portrait Sketchers 8.5/10

🪶 Tips for Using These Pencils

Always sharpen with a manual sharpener to avoid breakage.
Use blending stumps for smooth shading.
Keep a kneaded eraser nearby for clean highlights.
Store pencils flat or in a tin box to prevent tip damage.

🛒 Recommended Tools:

Blending Stump Set (Amazon)
Kneaded Eraser 2-Pack
Sketchbook for Pencil Shading

If you're just starting your drawing journey — go with Faber-Castell.

If you're already drawing portraits or realistic art daily — Staedtler Mars Lumograph will level up your work.

Both are excellent choices, but Staedtler wins for deep contrast and smooth shading.

✏️ My Pick: Staedtler Mars Lumograph (Pro Artist Choice)

👉 Check Price on Blick Art

🎨 Watch My Tutorial [https://youtube.com/shorts/hp_2SAGGoic]

Want to see how these pencils perform in action?

👉 Watch: "Drawing a Realistic Eye with Staedtler Pencils (Step-by-Step)" on YouTube

Drawing

Search This Blog